Where to Fish Beyond the Margaree River

We get it. The Margaree River is the crown jewel of fly fishing on Cape Breton Island. But what if you’ve already been there, done that, and tangled with a few silver bullets? Don’t worry — the Island is full of other watery wonders where the fish bite, the scenery stuns and the locals might even share a secret or two (if you bring snacks). Here are four other places to wet a line.

1. Chéticamp River

Nestled along the western edge of the Island in the shadow of the Cape Breton Highlands, the Chéticamp River is rugged, remote and a little bit wild — just like the fish you’ll find in it. This is salmon country, but unlike the Margaree, the Chéticamp doesn’t get as much traffic, so you might have a pool all to yourself (and a curious moose if you’re lucky).

Fishing here can feel like stepping into a Group of Seven painting — dramatic cliffs, misty mornings and enough bugs to keep you humble. Bring your waders, your patience and maybe an extra sandwich. This river makes you work for it, but that’s half the fun.

2. North River

Tucked away on the eastern side of the Highlands near St. Ann’s Bay, North River is the quiet achiever of Cape Breton’s fishing scene. Think calm waters, scenic surroundings and that peaceful, zen-like vibe you only get when you’re standing in a stream watching a trout rise.

This is a great spot if you’re looking for brook trout — or just a relaxing afternoon far from the crowds.

3. Bras d’Or Lake

Is it a lake? Is it a saltwater basin? Is it hiding sea monsters? All of the above? Bras d’Or Lake is a unique, brackish inland sea that locals treat with equal parts reverence and confusion. One thing’s for sure — it’s full of fish.

Expect to find everything from speckled trout and perch to striped bass and even some saltwater species. Try casting off the shoreline at Whycocomagh, Baddeck, East Bay or along the Barra Strait. You might even spot a bald eagle giving you the side-eye from above. Tip: fishing from a kayak is a great way to explore the lake and get to those quiet, tucked-away spots.

4. Tuna Fishing in Port Hood and Mabou

Ready to level up? Port Hood, on the Island’s west coast, is the gateway to one of the most exhilarating fishing experiences you can have — giant bluefin tuna. We’re talking fish that can weigh more than your car and fight like they’re starring in an action movie.

This isn’t your average cast-and-reel afternoon. Tuna charters out of Port Hood and Mabou give you a front-row seat to Cape Breton’s offshore excitement. You’ll need a strong back, steady nerves and ideally a camera to prove that yes, you really did hook a sea beast. Even if you’re just along for the ride, the stories you’ll bring home will be worth their weight in fish tales.

5. Englishtown to Framboise – The East Coast Underdogs

If you want to get a little off the beaten track, head east. Englishtown offers tidal fishing with a great chance of catching mackerel, sea trout and the odd flounder if you’re into flat fish with attitude. The ferry’s short, the views are great and if the fish aren’t biting, you can always claim you were just there for the scenery.

Further south, Framboise is one of those places that feels like a well-kept secret. Its river and estuary system are rich in sea trout and brook trout, especially in spring and early summer. Just make sure you have your bug spray, wear rubber boots and maybe don’t tell too many people you were here. Let’s keep this one between us 😉

Final Cast

Cape Breton Island is packed with fishing spots that offer more than just fish — they come with views, stories and the occasional surprise. Whether you’re after trout, salmon or something that could pull your boat around in circles, there’s a river, lake or salty stretch waiting for you. And remember, even if you don’t catch anything, you can always say you were just there for the peace and quiet. (Or to escape your in-laws. We don’t judge.)